Top 3 Performers
- Michael Johns - Starting to hit his stride and is picking the right songs to woo his strong female fan base but I have to deduct 2 points for rocking the ascot.
- David Archuleta - The boy can sing and emote when he has the right song.
- Brooke White - Even though the judges didn't like it, I thought it was great start to the show and she looks like a star on the stage.
Bottom 3 Performers
- Ramiele Malubay - She is just being outclassed by the other Idols.
- Jason Castro - It was just alright for me. Needs to make an emotional connection with the song he is singing. I liked how Idol skipped over the fact that this song was from a movie about a transgender individual.
- Syesha - Idol women have to learn that nobody compares to Whitney. Sure, there is big reward if you can pull it off but the road to Idol is littered with booted contestants who tried and failed miserably.